18 Movies Like “My Fault” That Will Give You All the Feels

If you loved the steamy forbidden romance and emotional rollercoaster ride of the Spanish film My Fault (Culpa Mía), you’re probably craving more movies with similar vibes. My Fault made a huge splash when it premiered on Amazon Prime Video in June 2023, quickly becoming one of the most watched non-English films on the streaming service.

The story follows Noah, a teenage girl who is forced to move into the mansion of her mother’s wealthy new husband. There, she meets her rebellious new stepbrother Nick and despite their initial disdain for each other, they can’t fight their intense attraction. Noah and Nick embark on a secret, passionate love affair, even though they know it’s wrong.

My Fault has all the ingredients of an addictive romantic drama – a complicated love story, sizzling chemistry between the leads, angsty push-and-pull dynamics, and shocking plot twists. If you binged it in one sitting and are going through withdrawal, don’t worry – there are plenty of other movies out there that deliver the same feels.

Get ready to swoon, cry, and fan yourself as we count down the 18 best movies like My Fault that explore similar themes of forbidden love, sexual awakening, class differences, and family dysfunction. From popular rom-com franchises to hidden international gems, this list has something for every hopeless romantic.

1. Through My Window (2022)

Fans of My Fault will find a lot to love in Through My Window (A través de mi ventana), another steamy Spanish romance that took Netflix by storm. Based on the novel by Ariana Godoy, this movie also features a simmering attraction between two people who shouldn’t be together.

Raquel is a shy teen who is hopelessly in love with her mysterious neighbor Ares. She spies on him through her window and dreams about him constantly. When they finally meet, sparks fly, but Ares’ wealthy family disapproves of Raquel. Despite the obstacles in their way, they can’t stay away from each other.

Through My Window has the same “wrong but feels so right” dynamic as My Fault. It’s a quintessential good girl/bad boy romance with tons of sexual tension, forbidden midnight trysts, and meddling relatives. If you want to get lost in another dreamy Spanish love story, queue this one up next.

2. After (2019)

One of the most popular teen romance movie franchises in recent years, the After series will give major déjà vu to My Fault fans. Based on Anna Todd’s bestselling Wattpad novels, After follows the tumultuous relationship between college students Tessa and Hardin.

Tessa is a sweet, naive “good girl” who falls under the spell of tattooed British bad boy Hardin. He’s initially only interested in her as a conquest, but real feelings develop as they open up to each other. However, their romance is tested by Hardin’s dark secrets, volatile personality, and Tessa’s judgy friends and family who don’t approve.

Like My Fault, After features an intense, consuming central relationship between two people from different worlds. It has plenty of steamy scenes, jealous fights, tearful breakups and makeups to keep you on the edge of your seat. With four movies out so far, the After series is perfect for a romantic marathon.

3. The Kissing Booth (2018)

For a lighter, funnier take on the “falling for the wrong person” trope, check out The Kissing Booth. This popular Netflix rom-com stars Joey King as Elle, a quirky teen who ends up in a secret relationship with her best friend’s older brother Noah (Jacob Elordi).

Elle and Noah have always bickered, but after a kissing booth fundraiser at the school carnival, they see each other in a new light. However, Elle’s friendship with Noah’s younger brother Lee has always come with one rule – his older brother is off-limits. As Elle and Noah sneak around and grow closer, they risk hurting the people they care about most.

While The Kissing Booth has a more comedic tone than the angsty My Fault, it still delivers on the forbidden romance, charming leads, and emotional conflicts that make the genre so addictive. It even has two sequels to continue Elle and Noah’s love story as they navigate long-distance and new temptations.

4. Endless Love (2014)

An underrated romantic drama, Endless Love is all about an intense, against-the-odds teenage love affair. Gabriella Wilde stars as Jade, a sheltered rich girl who falls hard and fast for David (Alex Pettyfer), a working-class boy with a troubled past.

Jade’s parents think David is beneath her and try to keep them apart, especially her overprotective father. However, their efforts only make Jade and David’s forbidden love burn brighter. They’re consumed by each other and willing to risk everything to be together.

Like My Fault, Endless Love portrays a once-in-a-lifetime romance that makes the young couple rebel against their parents and societal expectations. It’s the kind of dreamy, all-encompassing love story that will make you believe in soulmates while also exploring the danger of losing yourself in another person.

5. Amar (2017)

Another Spanish film perfect for My Fault fans, Amar is a coming-of-age romance about first love and sexual awakening. María Pedraza and Pol Monen star as Laura and Carlos, two teens who fall into a passionate relationship that becomes increasingly destructive.

Laura and Carlos are inseparable from the moment they meet, bonding over their shared love of cinema, art and poetry. However, their romance soon turns toxic as they become possessive, co-dependent and prone to jealous fights. Meanwhile, Laura also struggles with an eating disorder and pressure from her family.

Amar has the same intoxicating but problematic vibe as My Fault. It’s a raw, sensual portrait of young love in all its soaring highs and devastating lows. You’ll root for Laura and Carlos even as you recognize how unhealthy their relationship is.

6. After We Collided (2020)

The second installment in the After franchise, After We Collided picks up where the first film left off. Tessa and Hardin have broken up after the revelation of his cruel bet, but they can’t seem to quit each other.

As Tessa tries to move on with a new job and a nice coworker named Trevor, Hardin spirals without her, drinking heavily and picking fights. When they reconnect at a party, all their unresolved feelings come rushing back. But with Hardin’s self-destructive tendencies and Tessa’s trust issues, their reconciliation is far from smooth.

After We Collided amps up the drama, angst and spice, testing Hessa shippers’ devotion. Like My Fault, it portrays an addictive, messy relationship that probably isn’t healthy but you can’t look away from. Sometimes problematic fictional romances are the most fun to watch.

7. Chemical Hearts (2020)

Based on the novel by Krystal Sutherland, Chemical Hearts is a more serious, contemplative take on young love. Austin Abrams stars as Henry Page, a hopeless romantic who falls for new student Grace Town (Lili Reinhart) as they work together on the school newspaper.

Grace is unlike any girl Henry has met before – she walks with a cane, dresses like a boy, and has a dark, sardonic sense of humor. As he gets to know her, he learns about her tragic past and the grief and guilt she carries with her. Their relationship is tentative and complicated as Grace holds back parts of herself.

While not as overtly steamy as My Fault, Chemical Hearts has a similar melancholy yearning tone. It’s about wanting someone you can’t fully have and trying to save them from their demons. If you like romances that make you think and feel deeply, give this one a try.

8. Cruel Intentions (1999)

A deliciously dark and twisted romance, Cruel Intentions follows two wealthy, manipulative step-siblings as they make a sinister bet. Sebastian (Ryan Phillippe) is a shameless playboy who prides himself on seducing and ruining innocent girls. His step-sister Kathryn (Sarah Michelle Gellar) challenges him to deflower their headmaster’s virginal daughter Annette (Reese Witherspoon).

Sebastian expects it to be an easy conquest, but Annette resists his charms and he finds himself actually falling for her. As real feelings get in the way of their schemes, Sebastian and Kathryn turn on each other. All the while, there’s an undercurrent of forbidden attraction between the devious step-siblings.

Cruel Intentions is a sexy, scandalous thrill ride in the same vein as My Fault, complete with an illicit romance, conniving characters, and shocking betrayals. It’s the ultimate guilty pleasure.

9. The Boy Next Door (2015)

An erotic thriller starring Jennifer Lopez, The Boy Next Door is like an adult version of My Fault. Lopez plays Claire, a high school teacher who is separated from her cheating husband. When a charming younger man named Noah (Ryan Guzman) moves in next door, she can’t resist his advances and they have a passionate affair.

However, after Claire comes to her senses and breaks things off, Noah becomes obsessed with her. His infatuation turns dangerous as he starts stalking and threatening her, revealing he’s not the sweet boy he seemed to be. Claire must find a way to protect herself and her teenage son.

The Boy Next Door has some similarities to My Fault – the significant age gap between the lovers, a taboo relationship that shouldn’t happen but feels inevitable, and an element of danger. Of course, this movie is much more graphic and unsettling.

10. Endless Love (1981)

The original Endless Love movie, based on the novel by Scott Spencer, caused quite a stir when it was released due to its provocative content. Brooke Shields and Martin Hewitt star as 15-year-old Jade and 17-year-old David, who fall into an intensely sexual relationship against her parents’ wishes.

Jade’s father Hugh is so determined to keep the young lovers apart that he has David sent to a mental institution. When David gets out, he’s obsessed with reuniting with Jade, leading to an explosive confrontation with her family.

Like My Fault, the original Endless Love portrays a passionate teenage romance that becomes destructive and unhinged. It’s a wild, uncomfortable ride that definitely isn’t for everyone. But if you’re fascinated by doomed love stories, it’s worth checking out this piece of controversial cinema history.

11. Malèna (2000)

A haunting Italian coming-of-age film, Malèna follows a 13-year-old boy named Renato who becomes infatuated with an alluring older woman. Malèna (Monica Bellucci) is the most beautiful woman in their Sicilian town, but she’s also gossiped about and objectified by the leering men.

As Malèna endures harassment and ostracization while her husband is away at war, Renato watches her from afar and fantasizes about her constantly. He even starts stalking and spying on her. The film explores the pain and humiliation Malèna suffers as a woman alone in a judgmental society.

Malèna parallels My Fault in its depiction of forbidden desire and the allure of an unattainable woman. It’s a poetic, bittersweet film that reflects on the loss of innocence, the cruelty of mob mentality, and the ways we can dehumanize the objects of our lust.

12. Indecent Proposal (1993)

A romance with a provocative premise, Indecent Proposal stars Demi Moore and Woody Harrelson as Diana and David, a married couple who are deeply in love but struggling financially. When a wealthy businessman named John (Robert Redford) offers Diana a million dollars to spend the night with him, they ultimately decide to accept.

However, this decision has devastating consequences for their relationship. Diana develops feelings for John and considers leaving David to be with him. The couple must decide if their love is strong enough to survive such a betrayal.

Like My Fault, Indecent Proposal is a steamy, morally dubious romance that presents a tempting but dangerous choice. It asks the question of what people will do for money and if a relationship can come back from crossing that line.

13. Poison Ivy (1992)

A cult classic erotic thriller, Poison Ivy stars Drew Barrymore as Ivy, a manipulative teenage temptress who infiltrates a wealthy family. She befriends the insecure, chronically ill Sylvie (Sara Gilbert) and seduces both her father Darryl (Tom Skerritt) and her mother Georgie (Cheryl Ladd).

As Ivy gets a taste of the privileged life, she becomes determined to have it for herself, no matter who she has to destroy in the process. She tears the family apart with her mind games and sexual power, revealing the rot beneath their picture-perfect facade.

Poison Ivy has some thematic similarities to My Fault – the arrival of an unstable, sexually precocious young woman who upends the lives of those around her. It’s a campy, twisted delight with a deliciously unhinged performance from Barrymore.

14. Lolita (1997)

Based on the controversial Vladimir Nabokov novel, Lolita is the unsettling story of a middle-aged man’s obsession with a young girl. Humbert Humbert (Jeremy Irons) becomes infatuated with 14-year-old Dolores “Lolita” Haze (Dominique Swain) and marries her mother Charlotte just to be near her.

When Charlotte discovers Humbert’s sick fascination with her daughter, she flees in horror and is killed by a car. Now Lolita’s stepfather and guardian, Humbert engages in a sexual relationship with her as they travel across the country. But their twisted romance is threatened by another pedophile named Clare Quilty who also has his eye on Lolita.

Lolita is an extremely disturbing film that explores the depths of perversion and the way predators can manipulate and abuse young girls. It parallels My Fault only in the inappropriate relationship between an older man and a teenager, but it’s a much more serious, nauseating take on this taboo.

15. The Reader (2008)

Set in post-WWII Germany, The Reader follows the decades-long relationship between Michael Berg (David Kross as a teen, Ralph Fiennes as an adult) and the complicated older woman Hanna Schmitz (Kate Winslet). They begin an affair when he’s 15 and she’s 36, bonding over their shared love of literature as she asks him to read to her before they make love.

However, Hanna abruptly disappears one day, only to reenter Michael’s life years later when he’s a law student and she’s on trial for Nazi war crimes. As he grapples with her dark past, Michael reflects on the ways their relationship shaped him.

Like My Fault, The Reader portrays the long-term impact of a formative sexual relationship between a naive teenager and a mysterious older woman. It’s a melancholy, morally complex romance that asks difficult questions about guilt, complicity, and the stories we tell ourselves.

16. An Education (2009)

Another 1960s period drama about a young girl seduced by an older man, An Education stars Carey Mulligan as 16-year-old Jenny who dreams of escaping her sheltered life and attending Oxford. When a charming playboy named David (Peter Sarsgaard) enters her life and sweeps her off her feet, Jenny jumps at the chance for adventure and romance.

Despite the concerns of her parents and teachers, Jenny falls deeper under David’s spell as he introduces her to a glamorous world of jazz clubs, art auctions, and Paris getaways. She’s so intoxicated by her new sophisticated lifestyle that she considers giving up her education and future. But David may not be the Prince Charming he seems.

An Education is a coming-of-age story about a bright young woman’s sexual and intellectual awakening that shares some DNA with My Fault. It’s a bittersweet portrait of a girl on the cusp of adulthood, torn between her dreams and a tempting shortcut to experience. Mulligan’s luminous performance captures all of Jenny’s yearning and disillusionment.

17. Adore (2013)

Directed by Anne Fontaine, Adore (also known as Adoration) is a provocative drama about a pair of lifelong female friends who fall into sexual relationships with each other’s teenage sons. Naomi Watts and Robin Wright star as Lil and Roz, two women who have grown up together in an idyllic Australian beach town.

As adults, their friendship remains as close as ever, and their handsome surfer sons Ian and Tom have also become best friends. One summer, the lines between the two families blur as Lil begins an affair with Tom and Roz sleeps with Ian. The forbidden relationships continue in secret over the years, even as the boys grow up and pursue other romances.

Adore parallels My Fault in its taboo intergenerational romances that develop between people who are practically family. It’s a sensual, sun-drenched film that doesn’t pass judgment on its characters, but rather explores the complex web of love, loyalty, and desire between mothers and sons, friends and lovers.

18. The Diary of a Teenage Girl (2015)

Based on the graphic novel by Phoebe Gloeckner, The Diary of a Teenage Girl is an unflinching look at a 15-year-old girl’s sexual coming of age in 1970s San Francisco. Bel Powley stars as Minnie, a precocious aspiring cartoonist who begins an affair with her mother’s (Kristen Wiig) 35-year-old boyfriend Monroe (Alexander Skarsgård).

Minnie is hungry for experience and views the relationship as a thrilling adventure, while Monroe is more conflicted about crossing this line. As their affair continues, Minnie experiments with drugs, sex, and her burgeoning artistic identity. She grapples with confusion, insecurity, and a longing to be seen and loved.

Like My Fault, The Diary of a Teenage Girl is an intimate portrait of a young woman’s messy, exhilarating sexual awakening and the inappropriate relationship that shapes it. It’s a raw, honest film that doesn’t shy away from uncomfortable truths about desire, power dynamics, and the emotional turmoil of adolescence.

So there you have it – 18 movies like My Fault that will give you all the feels. From historical epics to contemporary tearjerkers, these films prove that love stories come in all shapes and sizes. Whether you’re in the mood for a steamy thriller, a nostalgic coming-of-age tale, or a sci-fi-infused romance, there’s something on this list for every hopeless romantic.