If you’re a fan of the classic 1999 teen rom-com “She’s All That”, you’ll love these 18 movies that capture a similar vibe of high school romance, makeovers, and feel-good fun. Grab some popcorn, get cozy, and enjoy this curated list of the best teen movies to give you all the nostalgic feels.
1. 10 Things I Hate About You (1999)
10 Things I Hate About You is a smart, funny take on Shakespeare’s “The Taming of the Shrew” set in a modern high school. New student Cameron (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) falls for beautiful Bianca (Larisa Oleynik), but she can’t date until her abrasive older sister Kat (Julia Stiles) does. So Cameron gets bad boy Patrick (Heath Ledger) to romance Kat.
Like She’s All That, it’s a charming story of an unlikely romance with plenty of laughs. The witty dialogue, stellar young cast, and sweet central love story make this a must-watch for fans of teen comedies. Ledger and Stiles have fantastic chemistry, and the film launched them, along with Gordon-Levitt, to stardom.
2. Clueless (1995)
Clueless stars Alicia Silverstone as Cher, a rich and popular high school student in Beverly Hills who enjoys playing matchmaker. Loosely based on Jane Austen’s “Emma,” the movie follows Cher as she navigates friendship, romance, and the daily dramas of teenage life.
With its iconic fashions and endlessly quotable dialogue (“As if!”), Clueless is a gem of the teen movie genre, much like She’s All That. Both films have a fun, upbeat energy and center around a lovable but somewhat superficial protagonist who learns to care about more than just popularity. If you love the humor and heart of She’s All That, Clueless is a must-see.
3. Drive Me Crazy (1999)
In Drive Me Crazy, neighbors Nicole (Melissa Joan Hart) and Chase (Adrian Grenier) devise a plan to pose as a couple to make their respective exes jealous. But in classic rom-com fashion, their pretend relationship may just turn into something real.
Much like She’s All That, Drive Me Crazy offers an engaging blend of teen romance and the challenges of high school social dynamics. Audiences who relish in the “fake relationship turned real” trope and enjoy watching opposites attract will find plenty to love here. Hart and Grenier make for a charming will-they-won’t-they pair.
4. Never Been Kissed (1999)
Never Been Kissed stars Drew Barrymore as Josie, a journalist who goes undercover as a high school student for a story and ends up reliving (and rethinking) her own teenage years. Along the way, she falls for a handsome teacher (Michael Vartan).
Like She’s All That, Never Been Kissed is a sweet, funny film about a girl learning to come out of her shell and gaining confidence. Both movies also deal with themes of identity and staying true to yourself. Barrymore is utterly charming in the lead role, and the movie’s message of self-acceptance is heartwarming.
5. Can’t Hardly Wait (1998)
Can’t Hardly Wait follows a group of teenagers on the night of their high school graduation party. Various storylines unfold, including a nerd (Charlie Korsmo) trying to get revenge on a jock and a hopeless romantic (Ethan Embry) pursuing his dream girl (Jennifer Love Hewitt).
With its large ensemble cast and intersecting plotlines, Can’t Hardly Wait captures the feeling of high school coming to an end, much like the prom setting of She’s All That. Both films balance humor and heart as they explore the ups and downs of teenage life and love. The ’90s nostalgia is also strong with this one.
6. Bring It On (2000)
Bring It On stars Kirsten Dunst as Torrance, the new captain of her high school cheerleading squad, who discovers that their routines were stolen from another school. With a national competition approaching, it’s up to Torrance to come up with new choreography and lead her team to victory.
Like She’s All That, Bring It On is a fun, energetic teen movie with a strong focus on school spirit and extracurricular activities. Dunst shines as the determined Torrance, and the film’s catchy cheers and impressive stunts are sure to entertain. Both movies also touch on themes of teamwork, leadership, and staying true to yourself.
7. The Princess Diaries (2001)
In The Princess Diaries, awkward teenager Mia (Anne Hathaway) discovers that she’s actually a princess and the heir to the throne of a small European country. Under the guidance of her regal grandmother (Julie Andrews), Mia must learn to navigate her new royal duties while still dealing with the everyday challenges of high school.
The Princess Diaries shares some key similarities with She’s All That, particularly in its makeover storyline and themes of self-discovery and confidence. Both films also feature a down-to-earth protagonist who learns to embrace her true self. Hathaway is utterly charming in her breakout role, and the movie’s mix of humor and heart is sure to delight fans of teen comedies.
8. A Cinderella Story (2004)
A Cinderella Story offers a modern take on the classic fairy tale, with Hilary Duff starring as Sam, a teenager who works as a waitress at her stepmother’s diner. She begins an anonymous online relationship with a popular boy at her school (Chad Michael Murray), leading to a memorable encounter at the Halloween dance.
Like She’s All That, A Cinderella Story puts a contemporary spin on a timeless story, with plenty of high school hijinks and romance along the way. Both films also feature a kindhearted protagonist who learns to stand up for herself and go after what she wants. Duff and Murray have sweet chemistry, and the movie’s message of staying true to yourself is sure to resonate with fans of teen comedies.
9. What a Girl Wants (2003)
In What a Girl Wants, free-spirited American teenager Daphne (Amanda Bynes) travels to England to find her long-lost father (Colin Firth), who turns out to be a wealthy politician. As Daphne navigates the ups and downs of British high society, she learns important lessons about family, identity, and staying true to herself.
What a Girl Wants shares some key similarities with She’s All That, particularly in its fish-out-of-water storyline and themes of self-discovery and acceptance. Both films also feature a charming, relatable protagonist who learns to embrace her unique qualities. Bynes is utterly delightful in the lead role, and the movie’s mix of humor, heart, and romance is sure to appeal to fans of teen comedies.
10. Just Friends (2005)
In Just Friends, successful music executive Chris (Ryan Reynolds) returns to his hometown and tries to win over his high school crush and best friend, Jamie (Amy Smart). The only problem? She only sees him as a friend, and he was once an overweight nerd who was firmly in the “friend zone.”
Just Friends offers a fun twist on the typical high school reunion romance, with plenty of laughs and heart along the way. Like She’s All That, it explores themes of self-improvement, acceptance, and the challenges of escaping past labels and perceptions. Reynolds and Smart have great chemistry, and the movie’s mix of humor and sentiment is sure to satisfy fans of romantic comedies.
11. Sydney White (2007)
Sydney White stars Amanda Bynes as the titular character, a tomboy who pledges her late mother’s once-dignified sorority. When Sydney finds herself at odds with the sorority’s superficial new leadership, she joins forces with a group of outcasts to take back the campus.
This modern retelling of Snow White shares some key similarities with She’s All That, particularly in its themes of self-acceptance and defying social expectations. Both films feature a down-to-earth protagonist who learns to stand up for herself and others. Bynes is charming and relatable in the lead role, and the movie’s message of staying true to yourself is sure to resonate with fans of teen comedies.
12. Easy A (2010)
In Easy A, clean-cut high school student Olive (Emma Stone) finds herself the subject of wild rumors after she tells a little white lie about losing her virginity. Olive decides to embrace her new “bad girl” reputation, but soon realizes that the truth is more important than any label.
Easy A offers a clever, witty take on the high school rumor mill, with Stone delivering a star-making performance in the lead role. Like She’s All That, the film explores themes of identity, reputation, and staying true to yourself in the face of social pressure. Both movies also feature a smart, relatable protagonist who learns to navigate the ups and downs of teenage life with humor and heart.
13. The DUFF (2015)
In The DUFF, high school senior Bianca (Mae Whitman) is shocked to learn that she’s considered the “Designated Ugly Fat Friend” of her more popular pals. Determined to reinvent herself, Bianca enlists the help of a charming jock (Robbie Amell) to give her a makeover and help her stand out from the crowd.
The DUFF shares some key similarities with She’s All That, particularly in its makeover storyline and themes of self-acceptance and defying labels. Both films also feature a witty, relatable protagonist who learns to embrace her unique qualities. Whitman shines in the lead role, and the movie’s mix of humor, heart, and romance is sure to appeal to fans of teen comedies.
14. To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before (2018)
To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before follows shy high school student Lara Jean (Lana Condor), whose life is turned upside down when the secret love letters she’s written to her crushes are accidentally mailed out. To avoid confronting her true feelings, Lara Jean pretends to date one of the recipients, the popular Peter Kavinsky (Noah Centineo).
Like She’s All That, To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before offers a charming, heartfelt take on the fake relationship trope, with plenty of high school drama and romance along the way. Both films also feature a protagonist who learns to open up and be true to herself. Condor and Centineo have incredible chemistry, and the movie’s mix of humor, heart, and swoon-worthy moments is sure to delight fans of teen rom-coms.
15. Love, Simon (2018)
Love, Simon follows Simon Spier (Nick Robinson), a closeted gay high school student who falls for an anonymous online pen pal known only as “Blue.” As Simon tries to uncover Blue’s identity, he must also navigate the challenges of coming out to his family and friends.
Love, Simon offers a fresh, heartfelt take on the coming-of-age story, with a focus on LGBTQ+ representation that sets it apart from more traditional teen rom-coms like She’s All That. However, both films share themes of self-discovery, authenticity, and the importance of staying true to yourself. Robinson delivers a powerful, relatable performance in the lead role, and the movie’s mix of humor, heart, and inclusivity is sure to resonate with fans of teen dramas.
16. The Half of It (2020)
In The Half of It, shy, straight-A student Ellie (Leah Lewis) agrees to help a jock (Daniel Diemer) woo his crush by writing love letters for him. But as Ellie grows closer to both the jock and his crush (Alexxis Lemire), she begins to develop feelings of her own.
The Half of It offers a thoughtful, nuanced take on the classic Cyrano de Bergerac story, with a queer, Asian-American protagonist at its center. Like She’s All That, the film explores themes of identity, friendship, and the challenges of navigating high school social dynamics. Lewis shines in the lead role, and the movie’s mix of humor, heart, and representation is sure to appeal to fans of coming-of-age stories.
Whether you’re into makeover magic, fake dating turned real, or just good old-fashioned teenage angst and self-discovery, this list of movies like “She’s All That” has something for every hopeless romantic. So queue up your favorites, grab your besties, and settle in for a nostalgic movie marathon that’ll make you feel like a lovesick teenager all over again.
Happy watching! And remember, you don’t need a bet from a popular jock to know you’re all that.
