The 2025 Broadway revival of Floyd Collins has taken the theater world by storm, earning critical acclaim and six Tony Award nominations, including Best Revival of a Musical. This powerful production, which marks the show’s long-awaited Broadway debut, brings a gripping true story to life with a stellar cast, haunting score, and innovative staging. If you’re a theater enthusiast or simply looking for a moving Broadway experience, here’s why Floyd Collins is a must-see in 2025.
The True Story Behind Floyd Collins
Floyd Collins is based on the real-life tragedy of a Kentucky cave explorer, Floyd Collins, who became trapped in a cave in 1925. The musical, with a score by Adam Guettel and a book by Tina Landau, not only delves into Floyd’s desperate struggle underground but also explores the media frenzy and human drama that unfolded above ground. The story captures themes of hope, desperation, and the human spirit, making it resonate deeply with audiences today.
First premiered off-Broadway in 1996, the show has developed a cult following for its intricate score and emotional depth. The 2025 Broadway production, presented by Lincoln Center Theater, elevates this story with a larger orchestra and breathtaking visuals, making it a standout in the current season.
A Stellar Cast and Creative Team
The revival features a remarkable cast led by Tony-nominated star Jeremy Jordan, who delivers a powerhouse performance as Floyd Collins. His rendition of “How Glory Goes” has been hailed as a highlight, showcasing his vocal and emotional range. Joining him is singer-songwriter Lizzy McAlpine, making her Broadway debut as Nellie, Floyd’s sister. McAlpine’s performance, particularly in the song “Lucky,” brings a fresh and heartfelt perspective to the role. The ensemble includes talented performers like Taylor Trensch, Jessica Molaskey, and Marc Kudisch, adding depth to the production.
Directed by Tina Landau, with music direction by Ted Sperling and orchestrations by Bruce Coughlin, the revival honors the original while introducing a grander scale with a 12-piece orchestra. The production’s lighting design, nominated for a Tony, uses clever techniques to evoke the claustrophobic atmosphere of the cave, enhancing the storytelling.
Tony Award Nominations and Critical Buzz
At the 78th Annual Tony Awards on June 8, 2025, Floyd Collins earned six nominations, including Best Revival of a Musical, Best Leading Actor for Jeremy Jordan, and Best Featured Actor for Taylor Trensch. While it faced strong competition from Sunset Boulevard, which won Best Revival of a Musical, the show’s nominations reflect its impact. Critics have praised its intricate score and the cast’s performances, with one noting that the production “demonstrates the power of clever lighting design to create space and depth — and to induce claustrophobia” (The Washington Post).
The cast’s performance at the Tony Awards, broadcast on CBS and Paramount+, was a standout moment, showcasing the emotional weight of the score and drawing new audiences to the production.
The Music and Emotional Impact
Adam Guettel’s score is a blend of folk, bluegrass, and classical influences, creating a hauntingly beautiful soundscape that captures the story’s setting and emotions. Songs like “The Riddle Song” and “How Glory Goes” are both musically complex and deeply moving, earning praise for their lyrical storytelling. The newly recorded Original Broadway Cast Album, set for release on July 11, 2025, features Jeremy Jordan and the full cast, offering fans a chance to relive the magic at home.
Why You Should See It
Floyd Collins stands out in the 2025 Broadway season for its unique story and emotional resonance. Unlike flashier, big-brand musicals, it offers an intimate yet powerful experience that lingers long after the curtain falls. The production’s innovative staging, combined with its stellar cast and score, makes it a must-watch for theatergoers seeking something meaningful and original.
The show is currently running at Lincoln Center Theater, and tickets are available through Broadway Direct, TodayTix, or Vivid Seats. With its critical acclaim and limited run, securing tickets early is highly recommended.
Final Thoughts
The 2025 Broadway revival of Floyd Collins is a testament to the enduring power of storytelling through theater. Its blend of historical drama, unforgettable music, and standout performances makes it one of the season’s most compelling productions. Whether you’re a longtime fan of the musical or discovering it for the first time, this revival is a theatrical gem that deserves a spot on your must-see list.
