If you’re a fan of Stranger Things or just love gripping theater, Stranger Things: The First Shadow is the Broadway show you can’t miss in 2025. This thrilling prequel to the hit Netflix series brings the eerie world of Hawkins, Indiana, to life on stage with jaw-dropping special effects, a compelling story, and a talented cast. Here’s everything you need to know about this Tony Award-nominated production, including recent reviews, key details, and why it’s a must-see.
What Is ‘Stranger Things: The First Shadow’?
Stranger Things: The First Shadow is a stage play that serves as a prequel to the Netflix series Stranger Things, set in 1959 Hawkins, Indiana—24 years before the events of the TV show. Written by Kate Trefry, based on an original story by the Duffer Brothers, Jack Thorne, and Trefry, the play dives into the origin story of Henry Creel, who becomes the sinister Vecna in the series’ fourth season. Directed by Stephen Daldry (Billy Elliot, The Inheritance) and co-directed by Justin Martin, the production is a collaboration between Netflix and Tony-winning producer Sonia Friedman.
The story follows young Henry Creel (played by Louis McCartney), a troubled teen seeking a fresh start in Hawkins with his family. Alongside him, we meet younger versions of familiar characters like Jim Hopper (Burke Swanson), Joyce Maldonado (Alison Jaye), and Bob Newby (Juan Carlos). As strange events and gruesome crimes unfold, Henry confronts a dark truth about his connection to the supernatural horrors plaguing the town, including the mysterious Upside Down.
Why It’s a Must-See on Broadway
1. Stunning Visuals and Special Effects
The production is a technical masterpiece, earning praise for its innovative stagecraft. From a jaw-dropping opening scene featuring a World War II-era ship to chilling encounters with creatures like the Mind Flayer, the show delivers Broadway’s most spectacular visual effects. Critics have called it “a technical tour de force” (TheaterMania) and “a breathtaking theme-park ride” (Show-Score), with illusions designed by Jamie Harrison and Chris Fisher, known for their work on Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. Expect smoke, strobe lights, and heart-pounding jump scares that bring the Upside Down to life.
2. A Gripping Story for Fans and Newcomers
You don’t need to be a Stranger Things superfan to enjoy the show. While it’s packed with Easter eggs for series devotees, the play is a standalone story that’s accessible to all. It blends horror, high school comedy, and heartfelt moments, exploring themes of love, fear, and family. The narrative centers on Henry’s descent into darkness, offering fresh insight into the Stranger Things lore while keeping you on the edge of your seat for 2 hours and 45 minutes (including an intermission).
3. Award-Winning Production
After a critically acclaimed run in London’s West End, where it won two Olivier Awards (including Best Entertainment), the Broadway production has garnered five Tony Award nominations in 2025, winning three: Best Scenic Design, Best Lighting Design, and Best Sound Design. It also received a Special Award for Illusions & Technical Effects, cementing its status as a theatrical milestone.
4. Stellar Cast and Performances
Louis McCartney, reprising his role as Henry Creel from the West End, delivers a haunting performance that earned him a Tony nomination for Best Leading Actor. The ensemble, including Alex Breaux as Dr. Brenner, T.R. Knight as Victor Creel, and Alison Jaye as Joyce, brings depth to both new and familiar characters. Critics praise the cast’s ability to balance humor and horror, with Variety noting their “fleet acting” that captures the retro Americana vibe.
Recent Reviews: What Critics Are Saying
The Broadway run, which began previews on March 28, 2025, and officially opened on April 22 at the Marquis Theatre, has sparked a range of reactions:
- Entertainment Weekly called it “a jaw-dropping, must-see theatrical marvel” for its thrilling spectacle and updated effects, like a massive Mind Flayer.
- Deadline hailed it as “a new standard for high-tech spectacle,” praising its jump scares and Stephen Daldry’s direction.
- The Guardian described the West End production as “breathtaking theatre with its own arresting imagination,” a sentiment echoed for Broadway’s enhanced visuals.
- However, some critics were less impressed. Slate called it “the worst Broadway show I’ve ever seen,” arguing it prioritizes spectacle over substance and feels like a teaser for the Netflix series’ final season. The Washington Post labeled it a “brand tentacle” that may confuse newcomers.
Audience reviews on platforms like Tripadvisor are overwhelmingly positive, with fans raving about the mix of horror, humor, and nostalgia. One viewer called it “a must-see for Stranger Things fans,” highlighting the engaging multi-scene staging and satisfying plot.
Key Details for Your Visit
- Where: Marquis Theatre, 210 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036 (inside the Marriott Marquis Hotel, third floor).
- Running Time: 2 hours 45 minutes, including one intermission.
- Age Recommendation: 12+ due to scary content, violence (including animal deaths), strong language, and depictions of mental health issues.
- Tickets: Available through Broadway.com, Ticketmaster, or the Marquis Theatre box office. Prices start at $64, with $40 same-day rush tickets (in-person, first-come, first-served) and a $45 online lottery. Group bookings (10+ tickets) are available.
- Accessibility: The theater is accessible via the A, C, E, 1, 2, 3, N, Q, R, and W subway lines. No on-site parking, but nearby options exist in the Broadway Theater District.
- Content Warnings: Includes gunfire audio, loud noises, explosions, haze, smoke, flashing lights, and strobe effects.
Tips for Attending
- Dress Code: No specific dress code, but comfy attire or Hawkins-inspired outfits are welcome. The theater can be cool in summer, so bring a layer.
- Stage Door: Located on 45th Street, across from the Minskoff Theatre (The Lion King). Perfect for meeting the cast post-show.
- Arrive Early: For rush tickets, get to the box office (opens at 10 a.m.) well before opening to secure a spot in line.
- Know Before You Go: Familiarity with Stranger Things Season 4 enhances the experience, but it’s not required. Avoid spoilers by steering clear of detailed plot summaries if you want a fresh experience.
Why It’s Worth Your Time
Stranger Things: The First Shadow is a thrilling blend of nostalgia, horror, and theatrical innovation. Whether you’re drawn by the Stranger Things universe or simply crave a high-energy Broadway spectacle, this show delivers. Its record-breaking 19 nominations across Tony, Drama Desk, and Outer Critics Circle awards underscore its impact, and the buzz on social media platforms like X shows fans are loving it.
Don’t miss your chance to step into Hawkins before the world turned upside down. Grab your tickets now and prepare for a night of chills, thrills, and unforgettable theater.
For tickets and more info, visit broadway.strangerthingsonstage.com.
